Rick McCarthy’s Public Comments 2-20-26

Rick McCarthy’s Public Comments
Good afternoon, my name is Rick McCarthy, LMFT, a former Subject Matter Expert and Oral Examiner for this Board. In 2003 this Board discontinued the oral examination, and California eliminated its only direct method for assessing applied competence at the point of independent licensure for LMFTs. This is the pivotal motivation that compelled me to advocate to reinstate the oral exams.
Public Safety is Our Primary Objective
Given my experience as an examiner, I am in a unique position, professionally and historically, to assess the level of competency in our profession. Since 2003, many of my professional colleagues and I have noticed a consistent increase of intakes complaining about the incompetence and unprofessional treatment with more recently licensed clinicians. Because of my 12 years as an oral examiner for this board, I am able to appreciate that since 2003, roughly half the candidates that I would have accurately assessed as incompetent or even dangerous, are now in practice as licensed therapists.
A Critical Point
Research across healthcare and professional services consistently shows that only a small fraction, often around 5 percent of clients who are harmed, poorly served, or dissatisfied ever file a formal complaint. Most harm is never reported, never investigated, and never counted. The good news is that correcting this is both imperative and possible. Newly developed structured oral or performance-based exams, using standardized scenarios, directly resolve the concerns that led to discontinuation in 2003. This is not a return to the past. It is a correction using better tools. I am also consulting with Senator Tony Strickland’s office on the legislative pathway to reinstate the oral examination for licensure Regardless of legislation, however, this issue goes directly to the Board’s public-protection mandate.
"Written exams tell us what applicants know.
Oral exams tell us how they put that knowledge into practice."
Thank you.
Got Something to Say?
These posts are based on the beliefs and personal experience of the post's author. Please feel free to leave your civil, constructive comments below. We try very hard to back up our statements with fact-based data and we ask you to do the same in your comments. You do not need to be logged in to leave a comment.
Become a Member!
Registration is quick and simple and the cost is very affordable. Join a group of like-minded counselors and take your practice to the top.
AMHP's Annual Conference
While this conference is targeted towards wholistic minded mental health professionals and related professions, as well as advocacy against the woke ideology, you are invited! Get CE credit and a chance to meet like-minded people. You've never experienced anything like this!
Therapy Disruptors Podcast Show
Featuring Kathleen Mills LPC-S and fearless moderator, Phillip Crum, we discuss topics no one else is touching and advocate for common sense. Listen on Spotify account or in the AMHP website for CE credit (members only). Tune in each week. It's fun!
Partner Programs
Our solid list of money-saving offers for tools and services you use in your practice. Website Development, Credit Card Processing, HIPAA Compliance Programs, EHR Platform, and Marketing Support, Use just one and cover your annual membership fee.!
Counselors' Community Webinar
Monthly event for AMHP Members this webinar features a monthly guest speaker, time for Q&A, and CE credit.