Clinical Integrity: A Call to Reinstate Oral Exams

Reinstate Oral Exams | Association for Mental Health ProfessionalsIn 2003, the California Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS) discontinued the oral examination requirement for licensure as a Marriage and Family Therapist (MFT). This decision, followed by the eventual elimination of the Written Clinical Vignette Exam in 2016, was justified as part of an effort to streamline licensure and align California with national testing standards. Yet, what was gained in speed and uniformity may have come at the cost of clinical depth, accountability, and public protection. I am calling for them to reinstate oral exams.

As someone who has personally witnessed and participated in every phase of the state’s mental health licensure exam process for over two decades, I offer this perspective with deep professional and ethical concern.

My Qualifications and Unique Background

I am Rick McCarthy, LMFT. From 1991 to 2003, I served as a Subject Matter Expert and Oral Examiner for the BBS. During that time, I not only administered oral exams but also helped write the clinical vignettes and develop the associated questions. When the oral examination was discontinued in 2003, I continued my work with the Board by contributing to the development of the Written Clinical Vignette Examination, and later, the Clinical Written Exam. My involvement extended through every stage of development.

This firsthand experience taught me one crucial lesson: no written exam can substitute for the diagnostic clarity, interpersonal evaluation, and ethical discernment gained through a live oral examination.

The Heart of the Profession Requires More Than a Test Score

Mental health therapy is inherently relational, nuanced, and unpredictable. The ability to reason through ambiguous situations, respond with empathy and clarity under pressure, and articulate ethical boundaries in real time, these are not abstract ideals; they are daily clinical realities. And they are competencies that cannot be fully assessed through multiple-choice questions or written simulations.

Oral examinations, by contrast, provide licensing boards with a direct window into a candidate’s readiness to practice. Through live interaction, examiners can observe verbal communication, emotional maturity, cultural sensitivity, and ethical reflexes, the very characteristics that determine whether a therapist is safe and competent to serve the public.

Importantly, recent research and expert consensus have raised concerns about the adequacy of current training and assessment methods. Studies on written-only exams reveal that they do not reliably predict a therapist’s competence in live situations involving emotional regulation, ethical complexity, or cultural nuance. Licensing based solely on written testing neglects essential domains that only oral assessments can capture.

Empathic EHR and the Association for Mental Health Professionals

Misguided Justifications for the Elimination

The BBS cited concerns about subjectivity, low pass rates, inefficiency and cost as reasons for phasing out the oral exam. Each of these justifications deserves a closer look:

  • Subjectivity is not a flaw but a necessity in the assessment of a profession rooted in human interaction. Therapists are not technicians; they are facilitators of healing in deeply human contexts. Subjective evaluation, when guided by structured criteria, is not only valid but essential.
  • Low pass rates, rather than indicting the exam, signal that the oral format effectively identified those not yet ready for independent clinical work. That’s not a failure; that’s an essential protective filter doing its job.
  • Efficiency and standardization should never be the primary values in a licensing process. While expedience may serve administrative systems, the mission of the Board is to serve the public by ensuring the competency and safety of licensed professionals.
  • The cost of anything of extreme value should always be considered in light of its long-term benefit. The expense of implementing the oral exams, which we have done before, pales in comparison to the costs; financial, emotional, and reputational, incurred by clients harmed through clinical incompetence. Ensuring quality at the entry level reduces liability, complaint investigations, and future remediation costs, and above all, serves the public need, as with all occupations that require excellence.

Meanwhile, training programs themselves have undergone a significant shift. Many newer graduates report feeling underprepared for clinical practice, citing limited live supervision and a reliance on theoretical coursework over practical, experiential learning. Compounding this, the growth of online and for-profit graduate programs has in many cases resulted in lower admissions standards, reduced faculty oversight, and minimal hands-on clinical training.

Some have interpreted the oral exams as an unnecessary barrier to entry into the profession. The quality standards that the public expects and deserves in an entry level therapist are the responsibility of the entire educational and training process before the candidate is able to demonstrate their competency by taking the State Board Exams. The State is not responsible for how the candidate navigates their training, but they are responsible through accurately measuring their clinical competency by the only proven means to measure those essential clinical skills, the Oral Exam.

Repercussions and Missed Opportunity

With the elimination of the oral and vignette-based written exams, California may have unintentionally removed its most meaningful layer of professional gatekeeping. While multiple-choice exams measure knowledge, they fall short in assessing judgment, tone, presence, and the ability to manage real-world complexity.

Across the profession, experienced supervisors have expressed concern that many newly licensed clinicians lack basic clinical instincts, such as reading nonverbal cues, managing high-risk disclosures, or responding with appropriate therapeutic empathy. I have personally watched candidates excel on paper but struggle to respond to live ethical dilemmas or communicate with clarity and calm. These are not theoretical deficiencies, they are risks to the individuals and families those therapists are meant to serve.

Furthermore, professional organizations, including the APA and NBCC, have increasingly voiced concerns about ideological influences and declining rigor in academic and clinical training. Complaints to state boards regarding clinician misjudgment or boundary violations, often involving new licensees, are reportedly on the rise.

Reinstate Oral Exams: A Call for Restoration and Rigor

The solution to California’s mental health workforce shortage cannot be to lower the bar for entry. A diluted process may speed up the number of licenses issued, but it does so at the risk of public trust, clinical integrity, and therapeutic safety.

The elimination of oral exams reflects a broader cultural and institutional trend of valuing quantity over quality, convenience over competence. But the results are evident: a profession increasingly staffed by clinicians whose paper qualifications do not always match their real-world readiness.

I respectfully urge the BBS to revisit the decision to eliminate the oral examination. If not a full reinstatement, then at least a serious exploration of hybrid models that combine the strengths of written exams with a live, scenario-based assessment of clinical reasoning and communication.

As someone who helped design, develop, and evaluate every version of California’s mental health licensing exams for over two decades, I can say with full conviction: we need oral exams not because they are traditional, but because they are irreplaceable. Any questions you may have, or if I can be of help in any way, please feel free to contact me.

Rick McCarthy, LMFT
Former Subject Matter Expert and Oral Examiner, California BBS (1991-2003)
Contributor to Clinical Vignette and Clinical Written Examination Development (1991–2016)

Got Something to Say?

These posts are based on the beliefs and personal experience of the post's author. Please feel free to leave your civil, constructive comments below. We try very hard to back up our statements with fact-based data and we ask you to do the same in your comments. You do not need to be logged in to leave a comment.

Become a Member!

Registration is quick and simple and the cost is very affordable. Join a group of like-minded counselors and take your practice to the top.

Therapy Disruptor Podcast Show

Presented by two firebrands and a fearless moderator, we discuss topics no one else is touching and advocate for common sense. Listen on Spotify account or in the AMHP website for CE credit. Tune in each week. It's fun!

Counselors' Community Monthly Webinar

For AMHP Members (yes, you can bring a friend!), this monthly webinar is where you can air it out!

Partner Programs

Our growing list of money-saving offers for tools and services you use in your practice. Use just one and cover your membership fee.

Annual Conference

Meet the people you've been taking to online all year and get your CE's completed. You've never experienced anything like this!

Preferred CE Providers

Meet our growing list of "Approved" CE providers. All of our providers meet the Board's requirements for "Approved Provider" status.

Supervisors Database

Every LPC and LMFT supervisor in Texas including their contact information and address. This is the list!

Rick McCarthy, MFT

About Rick McCarthy, MFT

Rick is a Marriage and Family Therapist who has been in practice for over 45 years. Along with his clinical experience, he taught for 28 years and consulted with the California Board of Behavioral Sciences in designing and conducting the State Board Exams for the MFT license. Rick lives in San Clemente, California with his wife, and enjoys gardening, surfing, and teaching springboard diving classes. Explore more of Rick's writings on his Substack.

Leave a Comment